Is HMRC’s IR35 checking tool accurate?

HMRC’s long awaited Employment Status Indicator (ESI) tool has now gone live, less than a month before the all-important IR35 rule change for limited company contractors in the public sector.
And it has raised a few eyebrows.

HMRC insist that the ESI isn’t completely finished yet, and so you might expect a few results to be incorrect, but some experts think that the problems go a little deeper than that.

Strange tribunal decision for online jewellery business
Editor | 10 February 2017
/ / / /

An unusual tax tribunal raises questions about online businesses paying VAT, particularly in cases involving multiple parties.

The case background:
The recent tribunal case concerned the jewellery business, Partnership, which had a very close working relationship with a sole trader – Alla Kisil T/A Jewellery 4 All.

In 2009, the two members of the Avalaya partnership lent US$60,000 to the sole trader, who was a personal friend of the partners. The loan was to be repaid in pounds sterling.